Adventures in Middle Earth the Road Goes Ever on Review

Open Preview

See a Problem?

Nosotros'd dearest your help. Permit us know what's wrong with this preview of The Route Goes Always On by Donald Swann.

Thank you for telling us about the problem.

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this volume, please sign upwardly.

Community Reviews

· 322 ratings · 12 reviews

Showtime your review of The Road Goes Ever On

Nov 08, 2014 Processed rated information technology information technology was astonishing

The melodies are not amazing, but my copy is a beautiful early edition from England: constitute in a used book store, it's like an artifact. For this small volume, Professor Tolkien wrote new Middle Earth material that expanded on a vocal Galadrial sang. This expanded material, the composer's conversations with Tolkien in the forward, and Tolkien's visually stylized presentation of Elvish-to-English translations make this one of the most special books I own. The melodies are not astonishing, simply my re-create is a beautiful early edition from England: found in a used volume store, it's like an antiquity. For this small book, Professor Tolkien wrote new Middle Earth textile that expanded on a song Galadrial sang. This expanded material, the composer'south conversations with Tolkien in the forward, and Tolkien'south visually stylized presentation of Elvish-to-English translations make this one of the most special books I own. ...more than

I'grand a musician, and so I was interested in what some of the many songs Tolkien has in the Trilogy might be like as existent songs.

Unfortunately, the composer was one of those modern types who wrote very modern (every bit in unusual harmonies and intervals, etc) melodies that wouldn't have been sung by anyone in Center Earth ...

I'm a musician, so I was interested in what some of the many songs Tolkien has in the Trilogy might be like as existent songs.

Unfortunately, the composer was one of those mod types who wrote very modern (as in unusual harmonies and intervals, etc) melodies that wouldn't have been sung by anyone in Heart Earth ...

...more

Oct 14, 2012 Linda Hoover rated information technology it was amazing

A collaboration between J.R.R. Tolkien and Donald Swann produced this fascinating book! This is some of Tolkien's poetry and songs set to music!! A must-accept for Tolkien fans! A collaboration betwixt J.R.R. Tolkien and Donald Swann produced this fascinating book! This is some of Tolkien's verse and songs set to music!! A must-have for Tolkien fans! ...more

A beautiful edition! I actually like the music composed past Donald Swann and the poems and illustrations past Tolkien.

May 31, 2018 Rowan rated it liked it

I recollect the "art song" settings of the poems don't fully practice justice to the depth of emotion expressed in Tolkien's work, and so I prefer many of the more contempo settings of many of these. That said, it is wonderful to know that Tolkien himself approved of Swann's melodies- it takes united states ane step closer to hearing the music Tolkien had in heed for his amazing poems. The book is beautiful, with Tolkien'due south flowing Elven script appearing throughout, and it was likewise fantastic to read Tolkien's translati I think the "art vocal" settings of the poems don't fully do justice to the depth of emotion expressed in Tolkien's piece of work, and so I prefer many of the more than recent settings of many of these. That said, information technology is wonderful to know that Tolkien himself approved of Swann'due south melodies- it takes us one step closer to hearing the music Tolkien had in heed for his amazing poems. The book is beautiful, with Tolkien's flowing Elven script appearing throughout, and it was also fantastic to read Tolkien'south translations and performance notes included nigh the two songs involving Sindarin and Quenya lyrics. ...more than

I think you would have to be a fan of Tolkien'due south to really savor these songs. The words may brand more sense if you know the context of the story of which they are a part. The music is unusual. It is not strictly piano/vocal, since the piano often does not play the melody. In parts, information technology is repetitive, and sometimes I felt like the vocal – non the road – went ever on. These are not melodies you would become away humming, but I don't think that was the aim of the composer. Not having read the books, my as I call back you would accept to be a fan of Tolkien'due south to really enjoy these songs. The words may make more than sense if you know the context of the story of which they are a role. The music is unusual. It is not strictly piano/vocal, since the piano often does not play the melody. In parts, it is repetitive, and sometimes I felt similar the song – not the road – went always on. These are not melodies yous would become away bustling, merely I don't think that was the aim of the composer. Non having read the books, my supposition is that the music was meant to fit the place and time of the story, and perhaps it does. Some of the music was discordant; some ended on half rather than complete cadences; some had unusual harmonic progressions and melodies. At that place were several I liked but there were one or 2 I'd never want to play again. ...more

I have the original book, equally well equally the vinyl record. I must acknowledge, I got five stars' worth of enjoyment out of them, more often than not because of the collaboration and blessing of the author, for whom I have profound respect and adoration.

That said, all the same, the tunes lacked the kind of authentic "aged and folky" feel that you would expect from the cultures Prof Tolkien created; they have a more than formal and 19th century parlor experience, and are not peculiarly singable or hummable.

I really much preferred the

I accept the original book, likewise as the vinyl record. I must admit, I got 5 stars' worth of enjoyment out of them, generally because of the collaboration and approval of the author, for whom I have profound respect and admiration.

That said, however, the tunes lacked the kind of authentic "aged and folky" feel that you would expect from the cultures Prof Tolkien created; they have a more than formal and 19th century parlor feel, and are not particularly singable or hummable.

I actually much preferred the arrangements created for the BBC recordings; they were believable, attainable and hummable. You can imagine them beingness sung, unaccompanied, past simple folk in simple settings, and they're the ones I fifty-fifty notice myself spontaneously singing, once in awhile. Still, I have a great affection for this collection, and treasure it for what it is.

...more

Not being much of a musician, I also listened to a youtube recording of this music. The music didn't experience very middle earth. Most of the songs seemed very hymn like, or mod. I thought information technology somewhat fit some of the songs, but for the well-nigh part, I couldn't picture the elves or hobbits singing in this fashion. The poems were the more interesting part. Non being much of a musician, I also listened to a youtube recording of this music. The music didn't feel very centre globe. Nigh of the songs seemed very hymn similar, or modernistic. I idea it somewhat fit some of the songs, but for the most part, I couldn't picture the elves or hobbits singing in this fashion. The poems were the more interesting part. ...more

Sep 24, 2011 Pratiti rated information technology it was amazing

I beloved the songs in this volume--my vocalisation instructor and I have been having so much fun with it.

3 stars because i merely read the translation parts... haven't tried playing information technology on the piano, since i don't play any musical instruments. three stars because i only read the translation parts... oasis't tried playing it on the piano, since i don't play any musical instruments. ...more

Tolkien canonical accommodation to songs of poems from LOTR. Outdated (specially afterwards Howard Shore's masterful scores) but withal... Tolkien approved. Tolkien approved adaptation to songs of poems from LOTR. Outdated (especially afterward Howard Shore's masterful scores) but still... Tolkien canonical. ...more